Business ETC uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 8 °C Friday 24 May, 2013

Passing ECB cut on to customers a ‘commercial decision for each bank’ – Dept of Finance

Tracker mortgage customers will see their rate adjusted as per the ECB change – but what about other mortgage holders?

Image: Julien Behal/PA Archive/Press Association Images

THE EUROPEAN Central Bank has announced a 0.25 per cent cut in its key interest rate, bringing it to a new eurozone-era low of 0.75 per cent.

The ECB’s refinancing rate is the rate of lending offered to commercial financial institutions to fund their operations.

The rate change will directly impact on tracker mortgage holders, because their rate is ‘pegged’ to the ECB rate and it follows its adjustments – both up and down.

On other mortgage products, commercial banks borrow from the ECB at its refinancing rate and lend to their customers at a higher rate to cover the costs. Given that commercial banks borrow from the ECB at the refinancing rate, the cost of their borrowing will fall by 0.25 per cent, according to today’s decision. So will they be passing that cut on to their other mortgage customers?

A Department of Finance spokesperson told TheJournal.ie today that:

Under the terms of the EU – IMF Programme of Assistance the pricing of financial products, including standard variable mortgage interest rates, is a commercial decision for the management team and Board of each bank.

In December, Taoiseach Enda Kenny urged banks to pass an ECB rate cut on to their variable-rate mortgage customers, though he ruled out introducing legislation forcing them to do so.

Responding to a query from TheJournal.ie this afternoon, a spokesperson for Bank of Ireland said that the bank’s tracker mortgage customers will have their rates decreased by 0.25 per cent as per the terms and conditions of their contracts.

Otherwise, “the bank will continue to keep other interest rates under ongoing review, while also referring to the continuing elevated cost of funding as highlighted in the Bank’s interim management statement published on 24th April: “The Group’s operating income and net interest margin continue to be adversely impacted by the cost of funding, the carry-over impact of intense deposit competition in the Irish market in the second half of 2011.”

Ulster Bank says that all of its customer accounts linked to the ECB rate will “move in line with the decrease” and its customers with standard variable rate mortgages (SVR) “will also see a decrease in their interest rate by 0.25 per cent from 4.75 per cent to 4.50 per cent”.

A spokesperson for Permanent TSB said that the bank is reviewing the situation at the moment.

Rates remain under review at EBS, while AIB says that its standard variable mortgage rate will remain unchanged.

AIB said in a statement: “The ECB base rate is not the primary determinant of AIB’s funding costs which are increasingly driven by higher priced customer deposits. AIB will therefore not be reducing the SVR on its mortgages as this would increase losses on our mortgage portfolio.”

National Irish Bank said that customers with tracker mortgages will have their rates adjusted in line with the ECB rate change.

Urging

ISME is calling on the government to ensure that the banks pass on this reduction to their customers “in full”. ISME chief executive Mark Fielding says this afternoon that the rate cut will likely be seen as an opportunity for banks to “maintain the benefit at the expense of their customers”.

“The banks should be forced through stiff sanctions, including penalties, to do the right thing and pass the rate cut on to their hard-pressed customers,” he said.

If this Government is to have any credibility, it will confront the banks, in particular those who have steadfastly refused to pass on reductions in the past, and force them, through legislation if necessary, to comply. It is about time that the requirements of the taxpayer received preference over the greedy vested interests of the bailed-out bankers.

Sinn Féin finance spokesperson Pearse Doherty has also urged the government to ensure the rate cut is passed on to mortgage holders and businesses across Ireland.

ECB cuts interest rate to record low >

Read next:

Comments (23 Comments)

  • that’s a no then

    Reply
  • All well and good if you have a tracker mortgage. I’m screwed on a variable rate – which will probably go up to compensate the drop for trackers.

    Reply
  • Sound follow-up from thejournal.ie. More pathetic light-touch regulation from FG-Lab.

    Reply
    • Well if the banks were forced to pass on every rate change the mortgage would just become a tracker mortgage…

      Reply
    • Why not David? Just because that’s they way things have always being done doesn’t mean it should not be changed. The banks would still be earning a higher return on a variable mortgage then on a tracker. Maybe slightly less but isn’t it about time they also started to support the people of Ireland? If AIB dropped there deposit rate slightly for instance then could they not absorb the 0.25%?

      Reply
  • Have to agree. Bloody scandalous. All us silly devils with mortgages to buy homes for the kids should know better, shame on us eh?

    Reply
  • I just re-read the article and see that Ulster Bank are dropping their variable – that’s good. Shame its still at 4.5%

    Reply
  • Thank god. I had a good financial adviser, come on the tracker

    Reply
  • If the government are to regain even a fraction of their lost credibility, then they need to act now, and force the banks to do the right thing. I won’t hold my breath though.

    Reply
  • I give up with the banks

    Reply
  • Mine is now at 1.65% yaaaaaaay

    Reply
  • Considering the government own most of the shares in the banks and the irish tax payer owns almost all the debt for some own known reason you’d think the clown noonan who just tell them to pass on the cut. nMaybe the journal should stop asking our ministers anything and go straight to their extremely over paid advisers and ask them what’s going to happen with the rate cut?

    Reply
  • So has anybody heard of KBC are passing on the cut m

    Reply
  • if the rate goes down then they should also pass it on to variable rate customers, remember if they went up then they wouldn’t be long passing on the increase, its variable for a reason i.e. not fixed, also we should remember that mortgage holders should indeed be helped, they will in the lifetime of their mortgage pay back huge sums of interest to the bank and have probably paid stamp duty to the government now household charges etc…. just my two cents

    Reply
  • plato 05/07/12 #

    My mortgage is a tracker with ulster bank.. God only knows when this interest cut will be passed on !

    Reply
  • Reg 05/07/12 #

    Most of the banks are bust and can’t afford to pass the cut on to variable rate customers. If the government forced them to pass on the rate cut it could mean that some banks would need more funding from the sates.

    Reply
    • Correct Reg, but, a lot of the banks customers are also struggling and need a helping hand. It must also be in the banks interest to try and ensure as few people as possible default?

      Reply
    • Reg 05/07/12 #

      I understand that Kerry and the banks have a lot to answer for. But why should the government (through the banks) subsidise just a certain section of society, that is mortgage holders?

      Reply
    • Because for the good of society and the health of the nation taking a to narrow view about ‘subsidizing’ a certain section of society is not the correct move. I think they said the cut would mean a ‘saving’ of 15 euro per every 100k on a mortgage? Would it not be better for the Irish economy if rather then that 15 euro being swallowed by the banks if it or at least some of it was released into the Irish domestic economy in the form of extra (albeit a small amount) spending be it on groceries or clothing or what ever it is spent on. Even if it was spent on a few pints in the pub it will help to stimulate a struggling Irish domestic economy. You can see as you travel around Ireland that shops, pubs, restaurants etc., are really struggling so a little economic stimulus would be welcomed by most it might at least help protect a few jobs and lively hoods and who know maybe even produce a few new jobs?

      Reply
    • Reg is right, only a subset of people get this benefit, and everyone ends up paying more to fund it.

      Government already generously subsidises ftbs through interest relief, this can be quite substantial. Given that about 1 in 4 adults do not own any sort of property, why should they be expected to continuously subsidise property owners?

      Reply
  • Pass it on to yourself, the euro is a dead duck and everybody knows it, start stocking up on tinned goods now.

    Reply
  • Nothing comes down . Greed is always the down fall when your bust !

    Reply
  • The problem here is that the banks profit margin is eroded further, which means they are less likely to give out new loans and more likely to squeeze those in difficulty. It’s a case of unintended consequences, a those consequences unfortunately fall on the economy as a whole.

    Reply

Add New Comment