Business ETC uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 16 °C Tuesday 21 May, 2013

Second ratings agency set to downgrade EU member states

Moody’s follows the lead of Standard & Poor’s, complaining about “the absence of measures to stabilise credit markets”.

A billboard in Spain reads:
A billboard in Spain reads: "End the crisis, create a company". Spain is one of the 27 EU states now at risk of a downgrade from Moody's.
Image: Paul White/AP

A SECOND ratings agency has indicated that it may downgrade its ratings of the EU member states – raising further question marks about the effectiveness of the deal struck by EU leaders last week.

In a brief statement this morning, Moody’s said it would revisit its ratings of all European countries in the first quarter of 2012, with the ongoing European debt crisis “in a critical and volatile stage”.

“The absence of measures to stabilise credit markets over the short term means that the euro area, and the wider EU, remain prone to further shocks and the cohesion of the euro area under continued threat,” Moody’s said.

The agency also argued that the deal reached by leaders in Brussels last week – where 26 European countries are set to sign up to stronger financial oversight rules – “offers few new measures”.

Many of the measures announced last week, it said, “are similar to previously announced ones”.

The warning follows that of Standard & Poor’s, which announced ahead of last week’s summit that it was putting every European Union country on ‘creditwatch negative’ – indicating a 50-50 chance that each country could have its rating downgraded in the next 90 days.

While stock markets have reacted somewhat positively to last week’s deal, bond market traders have indicated that the crisis is not yet over.

Though the cost of borrowing for the UK – which was the only EU member not to back last Friday’s deal – has fallen this morning, the costs of borrowing for Spain has risen to 5.9 per cent, and for Italy to above 6.5 per cent.

Moody’s is the only one of the three major credit ratings to rank Ireland at ‘junk’ status.

Explainer: Why would Ireland stick with the euro?

S&P puts whole of European Union on notice of possible downgrade

Read next:

Comments (14 Comments)

  • This just enforces how mind boggling Noonan’s statement was yesterday. It seems foolish and lazy that the government are not even considering a back up plan, should the euro blow up?

    Reply
    • I think this is a similar case to when Fianna Fail lied out of their teeth that the IMF were in talks with the Government. I feel that, no I hope that, Noonan is playing the same game! We need to be prepared. We can hope that those precautions never have to be used but as the saying goes… “Fail to prepare, prepare to fail!”

      Reply
    • He just has to say that. Have no doubt that they are preparing for a Euro break up. Every country in Europe is, large companies are.

      The deal will never be implemented as it is only a distraction and many elements of it would only speed up the decline. Most importantly, there is nothing to address the fact that the Euro is not economically suited for about half of the continent.

      This deal will never be implemented, Germany and France are going to have to be treated the same as every one else if this happens. Their deficits are well outside of the rules on this, will they accept fines, EU commission economic control and the implementation of immediate austerity.

      The agencies are finally doing their job and calling a spade a spade.

      Reply
    • @ Tim any sources? sounds like you have some insider information that would make good reading!

      Reply
  • Reading this depresses me more and more.

    Reply
  • Well Tim if France tries to impose severe austeriy budgets its game over id say.

    Reply
  • Total global debt: $150 trillion or 194% of global GDP.
    http://blogs.cfainstitute.org/investor/2011/12/08/competitive-currency-devaluation-part-1-of-3-the-feeding-frenzy/

    Now I don’t know much about global economics but if global trade imbalance of that extent can reflect how individual economies could each succumb to such market imbalance I think the rating agencys are playing games with the ratings and ignoring the overall situation particularly the rogue dollar in their own backyard.

    Reply
  • A “warning” issued by the controversial Moody’s! I’d call it a forecast aimed at promoting the downfall of the Euro.

    Reply
    • When this is all over, last Friday, will be seen as the EU once more refusing to engage with economic reality. The agencies are not saints but it given the numbers how can anyone say that Eurozone countries do not need to be down graded. If, a big if, last Friday’s agreement comes in to force, then the Eurozone will face a very aggressive downturn next year, as every country will have to cut at once. France and Germany would have to start introducing budgets like we have, or as last Friday stipulates the EU Commission would step in and do it for them.

      Reply
    • I’d be inclined to agree with Breda – I think that there was much that’s positive in the proposed approach, my main reason for favouring Ireland’s membership of the Eurozone on an ongoing basis is that I don’t believe that it will be possible to rein in the power of big business and “The Markets” otherwise than on a continent-wide basis.

      I’m in favour of European regulation and the Tobin tax, think it’s safe to say that the ratings agencies aren’t … I think that the agreement, as much as “refusing to engage with economic reality”, refuses to give “The Markets” what they want, and there will be consequences as a result, unfortunately. This is aside from the fact that I think there’s a vested interest in breaking up the Eurozone within the financial markets.

      Tim, I do take your points about the figures simply not adding up, but I also note that the UK can sell bonds at a lower yield than Spain, yet their level of debt is substantially higher. Why is that?

      Reply
    • At Niall. The UK has control of its own currency, it is using QE to keep yields down as well. So while it is in a hole like everywhere else, it still has options.

      Spain is stuck in a currency system that is way over valued for its needs and will not change to allow it to grow.

      Reply
    • Thanks Tim, sensible as always.

      Personally, I can’t shake the feeling that there’s more to “investor confidence” than tangibles, though … I think that the fact that the City clearly takes a privileged position in Cameron’s Britain, as evidenced last week, must have an effect also. How big an effect is of course open to question, maybe I’m just listening to my inner conspiracy theorist here.

      At this stage, I don’t want to see all of this be for nothing. I’m not at all convinced that a systemic crash isn’t imminent, mind you, but I think the only way of preventing this is to rein in the free market, and if that can be achieved, then at least the current turmoil won’t have been for nothing.

      Reply
  • The cost of borrowing for the UK has fallen? The markets don’t like this deal then.

    Reply

Add New Comment