Business ETC uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 11 °C Thursday 20 June, 2013

McGrath: Banks not passing on ECB rate cut is ‘disgraceful’

Only two banks in Ireland passed on last month’s rate cut to their standard variable rate customers, Fianna Fáil finance spokesperson Michael McGrath has said.

Image: Michael Probst/AP/Press Association Images

THE FAILURE OF the majority of banks to pass on the ECB rate cut to variable rate customers is ‘disgraceful’, Fianna Fáil finance spokesperson Michael McGrath has said.

There is speculation that a further ECB base rate cut may take place on Thursday this week.

At the beginning of July, the ECB announced a cut in the bank’s key interest rate to a record eurozone low of 0.75 per cent.

Today, McGrath said that the majority of banks with mortgage customers in Ireland have “disgracefully refused to pass on last month’s 0.25 per cent interest rate reduction to their standard rate customers”.

He said that the bank’s President Mario Draghi’s comments on the cut showed that the rate reduction “was intended to be passed on to customers and, as a consequence, to give a boost to the eurozone economy”.

The most effective boost to the Irish economy at the present would be if hard-pressed mortgage holders had more money in their pocket to spend in the domestic economy.

While tracker rate customers received the benefit of the rate cut immediately, two banks in Ireland passed on last month’s rate cut to their standard variable rate (SVR) customer as follows:

  • AIB: No. They increased their SVR by 0.5 per cent
  • Bank of Ireland: No
  • Ulster Bank: Yes
  • Permanent TSB: Yes, reduced their SVR by 0.35 per cent
  • National Irish Bank: No
  • KBC Bank: No
  • EBS: No
  • Halifax / Bank of Scotland: No
  • IBRC (Irish Nationwide): No

McGrath said:

The silence from Government on the failure of the State-owned banks to pass on the rate cut to mortgage-holders has been deafening.  At a time when variable rate customers expect their Government to act in their interests, ministers have sided with the banks.

He added that the Government “will presumably allow this to happen all over again if the ECB does decide to further reduce its rate on Thursday.”

A Department of Finance spokesperson told TheJournal.ie at the time of the previous cut that the pricing of financial products, including standard variable mortgage interest rates, “is a commercial decision for the management team and board of each bank”.

In December of last year, Taoiseach Enda Kenny urged banks to pass an ECB rate cut on to their variable-rate mortgage customers, though he ruled out introducing legislation forcing them to do so.

Read: ECB cuts interest rate to record low>

Read: Passing ECB cut on to customers a ‘commercial decision for each bank’ – Dept of Finance>

  • Share on Facebook
  • Email this article
  •  

Read next:

Comments (27 Comments)

  • Considering the stake Government holds in the banks, is it any wonder they aren’t saying much?

    Reply
    • hang on now ptsb had by far the highest rates of the lot of the banks cause they didn’t go into the bailout…. and they didn’t pass on any cuts before this one… so not giving the shower of money grabbing bas*#*#s any credit for finally passing on a small saving when they have pocketed the reductions in the ecb rate before this

      Reply
    • Agreed Cornelius, its often forgotten PTSB which is practically state owned have had rates as high as 5.2%, in fact even with recent reductions it is still 4.69%, i was amazed when I heard how low AIB rates recently.

      Reply
  • Isn’t it Michael McGrath who said it? Either way it’s FF trying to score brownie points yet again. Of course we should be getting every cent in reductions given by the ECB but this is Ireland..and sure ya don’t expect Inda and Baldy to go upsetting the lads..now do ya?

    Reply
  • I’m with Ulster bank but still haven’t received notification of the decrease do I assume I’m getting it?

    Reply
  • we are f**cked either way so you might as well have more money in your pocket as give more to the banks.

    AIB up 0.5% beggars belief, delighted I left them.

    Reply
  • AIB increase their rates!!!! Only in this little sh*thile country could this happen when ECB cuts rates. The people need to take stand some day soon otherwise your going to keep getting screwed over and over and over again. Fighting Irish me hoop!!

    Reply
  • Yes, it’s a disgrace, but Mattie isn’t the man to be pointing it out. FF should do the decent thing: quietly lie down and die.

    Reply
  • Just want to throw-up at the simplistic ‘slap on wrist” offerings of FF. Really, do they ever think ‘we’ will forget the mess we are in is due to their making – where indeed was this wonderful wisdom and insight then ! ! ! And to top it off FG/Lab are making matters worse in being spineless with our European friends. Drag the banks back in again and tell them by the grace of god and us they still exist and to cut their cloth accordingly – from the top down.

    Reply
  • Barry 31/07/12 #

    Ok so lets look at this,

    The banks are fecked and have state ownership or partial state ownership (some of them anyway), by not passing on the interest rate cut they keep the benefit and this helps them.

    Now if they don’t pass on the cut they loose yet more money and the government may have to help them out anyway, government money will also be taken from our wages etc so its going to hit us anyway and it’ll even hit those that decided not to take out mortgages etc.

    In short, just because a bank is state owned doesn’t mean the government can do magic.

    As for the non-state owned banks, well if they are private business then they can do what they want within the law. Not saying its nice and ideal but thats the way it is really I suppose,

    Reply
  • Who cares what Fianna Fail has to say? Why quote them? McGrath is Martin’s stooge, unable to form independent thought. He would be more sincere of he wore a leash and buried his head in the sand when people asked about the banking guarantee and the sea of corruption that surrounded his party for generations. Fianna Fail couldn’t care less about the hardship being endured by people across this state. For them, it is all about Fianna bloody Fail. Have we learned nothing in the last ten years? Yes, the banks are being ridiculous and disgraceful, and should be brought to heel for this outrageous act, but Fianna Fails attempts to ride popular anger should not be mistakenly portrayed as being sincere. They only care about getting back in power, and rewriting the history of the mess that they pushed eagerly on the state, so as to protect their friends. It’s in their nature to lie and say whatever is popular to achieve that end game. McGrath can shove his opinions! How quickly we forget…

    Reply
  • “is a commercial decision for the management team and board of each bank”. ? That’s like leaving the shark in charge of the fish, understandably the boards of each bank will have to be in charge of most of the decisions the bank decides to take but ultimately their main objective is profits and they’re not going to be to quick to implement these reductions if they can get away with it, the government should be taking action on this its a disgrace.

    Reply
  • State-owned or privately owned, makes no difference. Either way, as always, the bank wins, and either way the gambling debts of our so-called ‘wealth creators’ fall on ordinary people.
    It’s shocking that it takes a cynical FF stunt to have the issue raised. Most media, it seems, have thrown variable rate holders to the wolves by peddling the spurious notion that only tracker mortgages should reflect the ECB rate.

    Reply
  • forget the political boundries micheal mcgrath is the only credible voice asking these questions , its a pity he is FF as he the one TD whom i have any time for

    Reply
  • To: Terence.Flanagan@Oireachtas.ie

    I would like to raise the subject of the state owned Banks decision on variable rate mortgage interest being increased contrary to the latest cut by the ECB.

    My mortgage is with AIB and am advised they are increasing my variable rate by 0.50%.

    If the Bank is owned by the Taxpayer. You and I are both Tax Payers then where is my / our voice in relation to this.

    As my government representative please address with a view to action with the Bank to follow suit with the ECB.

    There will be a time in the future when the ECB increases rates and the Banks will be all so quick to increase rates accordingly.

    We should not sit idly by and allow this happen.

    I look forward to hearing from you.

    Kind regards,

    ‘Your name here’
    On behalf of the Taxpayers of Ireland and owners of the State Owned Banks

    Reply
  • Nothing disgraceful. S V mortgages are what they are. The banks are bust and in state hands which means you want the taxpayers to pay for you rate cut.

    Reply
    • Tax payers already pay to support the banks. Why should mortgage customers have to pay a double whammy?
      Also by reducing mortgage repayments and releasing money into the wider economy and thereby generating tax revenue, aren’t we also (indirectly) supporting state banks anyway?

      Reply
    • Barry 31/07/12 #

      Lisa, but then why should non mortgage holders have to pay up for the mortgage holders if the banks do pass on the cut ? (I say this as a mortgage holder)

      Reply
    • Correct Micheal , Its sickening but the likes of AIB make a loss if they pass on the cut because of what it cost them to borrow , so if they pass on cut they increase the loss on the taxpayer , this is a simple immutable fact but the irrational will still say pass it on anyway .yes I Agee they got us into this sh@t but do we want them to continue down an unsustainable path ??

      Reply
  • Take action. Email your local TD and raise your concerns. I did.

    Reply
  • AIB didn’t pass this on deduction and now hit its variable rate customers with a 0.5 % increase….not good at all….

    Reply
  • He says that the government is just allowing this to happen yet he doesn’t say he’d stop it if he was back in government….

    Reply

Add New Comment