Business ETC uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 14 °C Tuesday 21 May, 2013

Almost half of people are not saving at all – survey

When asked what consumers will do with spare cash, half said they would use it to pay off debt.

Image: rangizzz via Shutterstock

A NEW SURVEY by Nationwide/ESRI has shown that 47 per cent of people are not saving at all which is the highest recorded level of non-saving.

The Nationwide/ESRI Saving Index showed that just 28 per cent of people are now saving regularly which is a record low in the Index and down from 41 per cent in November 2011.

The Savings Attitude sub-index, which guages sentiment on saving behaviour, declined from this time last year from 112 to 96.

In November, 30 per cent of consumers think that now is a good time save compared with 27 per cent last month, and 27 per cent this time last year.

Although 44 per cent believe that now is a bad time to save, this has decreased from 48 per cent a month ago and 45 per cent in November last year.

On the negative front, more than half, or 57 per cent, believe that government policy discourages saving which is a 5 percentage point increase on November 2011.

Consumer intentions

When asked what consumers will do with spare cash, 50 per cent said they would use it to pay off debt, 39 per cent would save it and just 9 per cent would spend it.

A large proportion of savers are also uncomfortable with the amount they save, with 62 per cent  reporting that they feel they are saving less than they should.

Commenting on the index, Brendan Synnott, Managing Director of Nationwide UK (Ireland) said that over the course of 2012 there has been a consistent increase in the number of people who are not saving and a steadu decline in those that save on a regular basis.

“At the same time however, people continue to believe that they should save,” he said.

“There is positivity towards the idea of saving given the economic environment and the preference to pay down debt or save as opposed to spend also remains. This diverging attitude and behaviour has been apparent throughout 2012 and the budget is likely to further re-enforce this trend.”

Read: Budget 2013: Four days to go, here is the speculation so far>

Read next:

Comments (42 Comments)

  • Who has spare money. How can it be spare money if it is used to pay off debt. My idea of spare money is money not owed.

    Reply
    • Then maybe 20 people in Ireland qualify as mortgage is also debt :)

      Reply
    • David, another way of putting it is that paying off debt IS a way of saving. This article is contradictory

      Reply
    • Good point.

      Reply
    • Admittedly the act of saving is a discipline just like training.
      Eg: Get paid
      put 10%-20% away into savings
      then pay bills, look after health, eat etc
      and whatever is left over spend freely on lifestyle, luxuries etc.

      Unfortunately in Ireland the house is rigged by the government and their banking bedfellows,
      this due to the level of debt that they have imposed on Irish individuals.

      The current Irish example sounds more like this.
      Get Paid
      Borrow money from elderly parents to put with wages to pay mortgage, or get prosecuted by taxpayer bailed out corrupt Irish banker or (here today and gone tomorrow) corrupt foreign banker.
      Then if anything is left over pay taxes or get thrown in prison.
      Then if anything is left over pay car insurance or get prosecuted and possibly thrown is prison.
      Then if anything is left over pay home insurance, petrol, tolls, etc.
      Then if anything is left over pay for child care etc.
      Then finally if there is anything left over, have something (cheap) to eat (try the out of date section in local supermarket ,local soup kitchens, or elderly parent’s house).
      Repeat for 8-10 years, until crisis eventually sorts itself out, and our inept, banker owned government claim responsibility for the recovery and sail off into the sunset with 2-3 big fat taxpayer paid pensions.

      Reply
    • Take the €1000- €1500- €2000 per month 35-40 year mortgage out of the equation and replace it with a €400-€450 one and people will regain hope.
      Nobody on an average income begrudges paying a €400-€450 per month (principle and interest) on a 20 year mortgage on a well built, nice comfortable home that they will eventually pay off someday.
      Every bank (local and foreign) that operated in Ireland during the boom,
      operated with such levels of corruption/criminality that they eventually went bust or had to be heavily bailed out by the taxpayer, some of them to the point where they broke the entire country.
      They dished out money like confetti on a commission driven 100%+, interest only, 40 year, basis on nothing more than badly located deathtraps built by their cowboy bedfellows.
      But still our government protects them and treats them like gods.

      Already over a hundred thousand people have stopped paying their mortgage and put their wellbeing and the wellbeing of their families above paying false ponzi debts to these criminals.
      Many more will follow and stop paying.
      History will show that they have done the right thing.

      Reply
  • The only ones saving in our house are the two kids a few quid in the money boxes. The younger one doesn’t want to put his money in a bank because he won’t be able to see or count it. Maybe he has a point!!!

    Reply
  • What spare money?

    Reply
  • A lot of people are barely surviving let alone have any spare cash yo save. They’ll have a lot less after this week.

    Reply
  • Not everyone is in the same boat folks. Loads of people out there spending money, deffo loads in pubs at moment.

    Im lucky enough to be one of them. Decent paying job, lowish rent and no other major outgoings, but there are tons more like me. Not everyone is being hurt.

    Reply
    • Glad there are people like you otherwise there will be even more broken people out there. Even when it comes to social welfare spongers, still ok for econony if they spend that in the country. There is that extra return of what they get in another form – perhaps some jobs here and there. Merry Xmas :)

      Reply
    • Good on you and the very best wishes on a continuing comfort.
      Really nice to hear of folk doing well,long may it last.

      Reply
    • To true! I’ve been living in Ireland since May after moving here to be with my boyfriend. Since then I have had two jobs both paying above 9.60 an hour. There are plenty of jobs out there, people just need to apply and be willing to work for their money instead of having to rely on the over stretched budget of the government!

      Reply
    • Katie good girl yourself . Well done . Glad to hear YOU are doing so well.
      Great to hear a good news story too at long last. I can not praise you and your good fortune enough. :)

      Reply
  • People are spending on a “buy now,worry later” basis.
    The real cost of Christmas will show in January when the credit cards/overdrafts etc come in.
    That and if we get a severe winter will put a huge amount of families over the edge.
    People have no money for saving at all.

    Reply
    • Reminds me of the whole celtic Tiger generation. Enjoy now , dont think about later. Mortgages and holidays because we had decent jobs… nothing could go wrong! I’m not blaming those who took out mortgages during the good times as the banks were puking out the cash so were also to blame. I would just hope people with excess cash these days are being more cautious as a lesson learned from the current mess the country is in.

      Reply
  • It’s impossible to save when so much of people’s hard earned money is wasted on the futile attempt to rebuild the country.

    Reply
  • I used to be able to save a few quid but now i am lucky to have a few quid to spend……

    Reply
  • I’ve not experienced the recession yet as I’m paid by the EU and not an Irish source.. joys of being a student. However even though ample money for my current needs are coming in on a monthly basis… After bills I’m left with little to actually save. I can’t imagine the families who have children where you can’t simply decide to skip a meal to save some cash. I’ve had to do this already…but I wouldn’t classify that as tough as my decisions don’t impact on little ones. The banks and failings of our government have resulted in the destruction of so many basic needs and have resulted in the death of so many desperate citizens. They have murdered these people through their selfish acts…to line their pockets. I hope they rot in hell for their miss handling and for trying to make US feel that it was OUR doing!!!!

    Reply
    • Hear Hear
      Kieran.
      That’s the truth.
      The disgusting facts are, that the banks and the government are fully aware of this torture that they choose to inflict on innocent people.
      Unfortunately our bought out media, keep their mouths shut about these travesties.

      Reply
  • @Mike – Apologies for that I read your comment and got things completely arseways.

    Reply
  • What is spare cash?this is Sunday and I have €10 in my pocket and I don’t drink r smoke I have two small children and I have €10 until Wednesday but still the government want to cut child benefit and possibly job seekers and at the same time rise the rent on my council house don’t make sense.

    Reply
  • there is no spare money for god sake. it costs me 50 euro per week TO GO to work. absolutely sickening. would be far better off on social welfare then i could spend time with my kids instead of paying other people to rear them while im working. if i did have money to save i would save it. this has been the hardest winter by far and its only beginning.

    Reply
  • If you save you might fail means test and end up ………………

    Reply
  • what’s saving??? my wages barely cover my shelter food and bills never mind having extra money to save

    Reply
  • Just back from shopping centre. Mental busy, still 3 weeks to Christmas. Car park packed, any food catering packed and loads of people with 200 or more Euros packed trolleys. Is that really recession I wonder…?

    Reply
  • I honestly thought the money number would be higher. That makes me feel worse about my situation!

    Reply
  • @Mike – Typical tripe.

    I am doing ok and thats because i don’t have loans or mortgages to pay out, but only in Ireland are you beaten down for not being broke.

    Land of begrudging feckers

    Reply
  • Well I’m broke anyway!

    Reply
  • Broke and no money for savings.

    Reply
  • I’m a low-paid but full-time civil servant (yes there are plenty of us) and after rent + bills I can afford to put away €200/month (standing order from my bank into savings so I don’t even have to think about it). After 5+ years saving I have a small nest egg cos I don’t often p1ss my money away every weekend.

    Reply
    • arent you great?

      Reply
    • What is with the ‘servant’ thing. Seriously, why do we never refer to private sector workers as servants? It implies a greater degree if loyalty and commitment to the work that I see no evidence to suggest is there.
      I’m reclaiming the word and from here on will refer to myself as a private sector servant.

      Reply
    • lucky you ! what you save each month is eqivalent to what myself and my wife have to live on each week. yes 200 euro per week thats all, out of that we have to pay 87 euro in rent, because we have to rent private as the council has no suitable housing . i don’t begrudge you your savings, but there are also ” plenty of us” out here living on or below the breadline, and after this wednesday god only knows how we will get by.

      Reply

Add New Comment