Business ETC uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 12 °C Monday 20 May, 2013

Google privacy policy changes are ‘in breach of EU law’

The European Union justice commissioner has raised doubts about the legality of the changes the search giant has made to its privacy policy today.

Image: Mark Lennihan/AP/Press Association Images

THE EUROPEAN UNION’S Justice Commissioner has said that Google’s changes to its privacy policy are in breach of European law.

Viviane Reding’s comments to BBC Radio 4 came on the day the search engine giant initiated the changes which see private data collected by one Google service being used across other platforms run by the company including YouTube, Gmail and Blogger.

Google says the changes – which see a user’s web history and browsing data gathered and used across its websites – are designed to tailor search results more effectively for users as well as offer better and more targeted advertising.

The company believes its new policy complies with EU law despite doubts being raised in France where the data protection watchdog CNIL wrote to the company to urge a “pause” in the roll out of the changes.

Reding told the BBC that Google’s new policy was a breach of EU data protection law: “That is exactly what the data protection authorities in Europe have come to the conclusion,” she said, adding that the conclusions from an initial CNIL investigation had left her “deeply concerned”.

She has also told the Guardian that data protection commissioners in 27 EU countries have “strong doubts” about the legality of Google’s changes.

Google has insisted that it it happy to meet with CNIL and answer any concerns it may have but the company’s global privacy counsel, Peter Fleischer, added:

We are committed to providing our users with a seamless experience across Google’s services, and to making our privacy commitments to them easy to understand

Various technology blogs and websites have offered advice to internet users about how to ensure that their Google search histories and browsing data are not used by the tech giant across around 60 different services.

Read: How to delete your Google browsing history ahead of new privacy policy

Read next:

Comments (26 Comments)

  • I just googled “Are the changes to Google infringing on peoples privacy?”

    The top result was:
    “No they’re not David and by the way, you left the immersion on.”

    Reply
  • Interesting that it is primarily the EU that takes the lead on privacy issues regarding multinational companies and agencies. Remember it was the European Commission that faced down Microsoft for illegally bundling its services hitting them with massive fines.also the Commission that is bringing Intel to heel for its anti-competitive practices and is now challenging Google. In the face of the wide economic power of multinationals and their capacity to play one country against another, it is hugely important that we have the EU to face them down.

    Reply
  • Should you feel you don’t want
    Anybody tracking or using your personal information use this site to avoid all that!
    http://duckduckgo.com
    But I bet ye won’t! Google rules!! :-b

    Reply
  • I’ve been aware of this for about a month and have been opening up a new email address and as of today won’t be using google search anymore. I must say, the Internet is turning into one hell of a scary place.

    Reply
  • I don’t think people here understand exactly what new privacy policy means… It’s not like they are going to sell your data to other people. It just mean that they will be sharing them within the company…

    In fact if our government did such thing, where revenue exchanges data with social welfare, we would safe millions…

    either way with this much cash in hand – Google doesn’t care. They can pay hundreds of millions in penalties and just move on as if nothing happened…

    Reply
    • Are you naive? You believe everything they tell you. Google will eventually have a complete profile of all their users. And yes they can sell that info if they so please. Would you like your health care insurance provider knowing you order pizza online? You need to really think about the implications and the power this super information corporation has. Remember, they even know what your house looks like!!

      Reply
    • I haven’t read the policy, but I am almost certain that It does somewhere contain a provision precluding Google from selling their information to companies outside the 60 in the google group.

      Reply
    • Joe – I’m not naive, I can read. Did you even bother to read it???

      Google still knows you bought pizza online. with new privacy policy or not. I think you’re the naive one.

      Reply
    • Ah for god sake! Its not about google knowing your online activity its about the information being stored shared or sold. Doesnt matter. Forget it.

      Reply
    • And further more dont base all your assumptions on this journal article, research it properly! If an individual googled (for example) debt help agencies, this info could be accessed by the credit services agencies eventually so they inturn could also build a profile on that individual, and probaby black ball that person for a loan. Bigger picture!!

      Reply
    • That’s not correct Joe – a credit agency cannot in any way have access to information about what you searched for.

      Reply
    • Joe – you seem to have some weird idea… again, Google isn’t going to share this information with anyone. READ THEIR NEW POLICY… Then come back and we can have a discussion.

      Reply
  • Mmmm… pizza!!

    Reply
  • The amount of scaremongering on this thread is baffling. This policy change does not, in any way, change the data that Google collects – no more, no less.

    The only difference is that they will treat you as a single signed in user across all of their products – this has already been evident in things like Google Calendar, when it autocompletes contacts from your Gmail contact list.

    Private information is a private as it ever was, nothing being released to any third parties, and users still have choice and control when it comes to what’s tracked and what isn’t – Google Chrome has an incognito mode to make this even easier.

    Reply
  • And what are the chances of the EU forcing Google to reverse the new privacy policy..None!

    Reply
  • Simple way to sort it: Use Yahoo as your default search engine….

    Reply
  • Imo google are just doing this as another step in making the black line above the search pages work better. I’ve started using Google a lot more due to android and like how they are attempting to merge all my data in one place.

    Reply
    • But that’s the thing – people who don’t understand are starting to panic for no reason.

      So, the ads Google display may actually be useful to me, based on ASSUMPTIONS being made out of my search history etc. – is this really that bad??? I may find even something useful, and will click on it more often. More cash for them, more personal experience to me… sounds like win-win…

      Anyone who believe that businesses are not trying to profile them by any means possible are fooling themselves. What about your Tesco card huh??? :)

      Reply
  • jimbo 02/03/12 #

    Up yours google nosey twats

    Reply
  • cimada 02/03/12 #

    I made sure I cleared google web history which pauses it forever unless you start it again, now nothing to exchange with anyone…

    Reply
  • I use yahoo it’s amazing .. I can store my credit card there my home address all my passwords a copy of my birth cert just in case. and it’s all encrypted

    Reply

Add New Comment