Business ETC uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 5 °C Thursday 23 May, 2013

Fitch: Yes vote removes uncertainty, but return to markets still ‘unclear’

The ratings agency says approving the Fiscal Compact removes a risk, but doesn’t guarantee a return to the markets.

Image: HENNY RAY ABRAMS/AP

ONE OF THE WORLD’S largest ratings agencies has said Ireland’s decision to ratify the Fiscal Compact is a welcome one which removes uncertainty about Ireland’s future funding – but that the country’s fiscal future remains “unclear”.

Fitch has said the Yes vote in last Thursday’s referendum was “positive for the sovereign”, as it removed the concern about whether Ireland could gain access to the European Stability Mechanism if it needed it.

It added, though, that the Yes vote “does not put upward pressure” on its BBB+ rating, only a couple of notches above ‘junk’ status – given that the country was still set to run significant deficits in the coming years.

“Export-orientated Ireland is exposed to an economic downturn in its major European trading partners, though its improving competitiveness mitigates the impact of such adverse external shocks,” it said.

Noting the yield of Irish government bonds, which this morning stand above 7.4 per cent for 9-year loans, Fitch declares that “the timing and cost of Ireland’s return to the debt markets remain unclear”.

“These concerns are reflected in our Negative Outlook on the rating, which we affirmed on 27 January,” it said.

Fitch also suggested that the government’s deficit this year will stand at 8.6 per cent of GDP, compared to the 8.3 per cent currently projected by both the Department of Finance and the EU.

That 8.6 per cent, however, is within the boundaries laid down under Ireland’s bailout agreement, which allowed a deficit of up to 8.6 per cent of GDP.

On a positive note, the agency remarks that Ireland remains on track to exceed many of the EU-IMF targets, and said the Yes vote was an expression of “broader public acceptance” of a long-term fiscal consolidation plan.

After the global financial crisis, why are rating agencies still trusted?

In numbers: Ireland’s referendum on the Fiscal Compact

Read next:

Comments (19 Comments)

  • ‘yes vote removes uncertainty, but return to markets still unclear…’
    So uncertainty HASN’T been removed. I can’t believe we are expected to buy into this waffle! Sick and tired of the Irish people being held to ransom by markets, ratings agencies, Europe and our own gov!

    Reply
  • Hmmm, just few days after the yes vote and we have one credit agency saying the yes vote does not make the slightest difference and one of Merkels ministers dashing Edna’s hopes of a new Bank Debt deal, one wonders what was the point of it all?

    Reply
  • Kinda impossible to get a deal of any description when you’ve thrown your cards in. As for Enda playing hardball….lol

    Reply
  • Positive for the sovereign !!! What sovereignty ?? We gave that away !!!

    Reply
  • I see Enda was refused a new deal on our bailout, well what did he expect a pat on the back for our Country voting yes, Germany dont need to be nice to us now, sure are we not great housekeepers…..

    Reply
  • Stupid, stupid people

    Reply
  • Fitch is full of shit

    Reply
    • If Ireland returns to the markets, it will be the second nation in history to have done so without either a currency devaluation or debt restructuring. Britain achieved this 200 years ago. When it had an empire and it’s early industrial revolution economy was growing rapidly. The non-existence of workers rights and child labour laws aided this.
      In other words, Ireland has ceased to be a self-financing nation and will not be returning to the markets this side of a Euro implosion.

      Reply
  • @ Sean, I was reading up on Germany’s labour reforms over the last decade “Hartz reform” as that’s what I believe will be shoved down our throat to survive.. Written by Peter Hartz, Ceo of VW. The real fight is yet to come which will be hard as we have let the draw bridge down. The Germans are in employment but life is tough and employment uncertain for the man on the street.

    Reply
  • Another blow to the “ah sure we’ll get the money from somewhere” NO voters.

    Reply
    • I wonder what orifice Inda promised them to hold off that “revelation” until days after the vote… I hope they gave him a kiss first at least. oh yes that fiscal compact is working a treat already for his mistress in Germany as she get him fitted for his gimp suit.

      Reply
    • We have learned nothing from the centuries of struggle to gain our sovereignty. Our independence time and again, gained at so high a price by many, is lost by the short-sighted gains of the few.
      Why have we forgotten the Leinstermen who threw their lot in with the invading Danes? McMurrough who aided the Norman’s? The Irish Parliament that ratified the Act of Union?
      Our constitution was gifted to us by the founders of this state to protect the populace from political excesses is now trampled as an impediment to political expedience. An unacceptable barrier to the enhanced powers of poltical incompetence. Democracy no longer holds any currency. While currency ceases to hold any value.
      Irish independence and sovereignty has never been lost without those on the inside selling it for their own ends. It is only ever cherished when it is gone. And is much more difficult to recapture than it is to surrender.

      Reply
    • Where do you say Ireland will get funding from David. ESM was at best an illusory carrot for gullible and naive.

      Economics Prof says Spanish funding requirements- €500 Billion:
      “This contagion is spreading faster than we can stop now,” Blanchflower, an economics professor at Dartmouth and former Bank of England policy maker, said in a radio interview on “Bloomberg Surveillance” with Tom Keene and Ken Prewitt. “You need to do something in a week, and it would take these guys a year to work it out.”
      With markets bracing for further deterioration in Spain’s finance sector and a possible Greek departure from the 17-member euro area, Spanish Prime Minister Mariano Rajoy on June 2 added his voice to calls for a “banking union” in Europe involving a centralized system to re-capitalize lenders.
      German Chancellor Angela Merkel shut off another crisis- fighting avenue the same day as she toughened her opposition to euro-area debt sharing, saying that “under no circumstances” would she agree to euro bonds.
      Paul De Grauwe, a professor at the London School of Economics & Political Science, has proposed a blanket bond markdown across Europe. European nations lack the cooperation required to execute such a plan, Blanchflower said.
      Yields on German two-year notes fell below zero for the first time ever last week as investors fled riskier sovereign debt. Spanish bonds dropped for a fourth week, pushing the country’s 10-year yields above 6.5 percent — nearing the 7 percent threshold which triggered the three earlier bailouts.
      Spain plans to sell bonds maturing in 2014, 2016 and 2022 on June 7. The amount hasn’t yet been set. Blanchflower estimates that the nation will need to raise about 500 billion euros ($625 billion).
      Bloomberg 04/06/12

      Reply
  • Zartan 05/06/12 #

    Sadly there’ll be no chance of hardball with Kenny at the helm – he is a ridiculously lightweight and insubstantial figure. Casper the Friendly Ghost would have more substance and gravitas as a negotiator.

    Reply
  • as far as I can see, it didnt make any difference if we would of voted no… but thanks to enda he tryed his best to make a deal after voting, but little too late…its time for the gov to put the gloves on against germany and start playin hardball with merkel and co.

    Reply

Add New Comment