Business ETC uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 11 °C Wednesday 19 June, 2013

Cyprus to exempt small savers from deposit tax ahead of crucial vote

Accounts with balances under €20,000 will be exempted from a controversial levy if it is approved by MPs today.

Cypriot citizens have condemned a deeply unpopular levy on domestic bank accounts, as part of the island's €10 billion bailout deal.
Cypriot citizens have condemned a deeply unpopular levy on domestic bank accounts, as part of the island's €10 billion bailout deal.
Image: Petros Karadjias/AP

Updated, 11:23

THE GOVERNMENT of Cyprus has proposed to exempt certain bank accounts from a controversial levy that forms the backbone of a deal to secure a €10 billion European bailout, ahead of a major parliamentary vote to guarantee the deal.

MPs are due to vote at 6pm local time (4pm Irish time) on the bailout deal, which will see Eurozone countries offer €10 billion in emergency funding for the struggling island – with Cyprus due to come up with another €7 billion itself.

While about a fifth of the domestic amount is to be found by burning junior bondholders at the country’s main banks, €5.6 billion of the funding is to come from a deeply controversial one-off ‘stability levy’ – essentially a tax on the balances of bank accounts.

The original deal struck by EU ministers late on Friday night would see a tax of 6.75 per cent on bank accounts with balances of under €100,000, with the rate rising to 9.9 per cent for higher balances.

Because of the unprecedented nature of the charge, however – which has forced European authorities to insist that similar measures would not be applied in other bailed-out countries like Greece, Ireland or Portugal – talks are now continuing to restructure this leg of the deal.

This morning the government published draft legislation which provided an exemption for accounts under €20,000 – but did not increase the levy on higher accounts. The Wall Street Journal said this could mean a shortfall of €300 million in the final fundraising total.

‘More progressivity’ in controversial bank levy

Last night Jeroen Dijsselbloem, the Dutch finance minister who acts as the president of the ‘Eurogroup’ of Eurosone finance ministers, had said Cypriot authorities would introduce “more progressivity in the one-off levy” before it was presented to the parliament for its approval.

Reports this morning had touted two alternative models – one with a 3 per cent levy for balances under €100,000, 15 per cent for balances over €500,000, and 6.75 per cent for savers in between; the second with no levy at all on accounts under €100,000, and 15.6 per cent on balances over €500,000.

The levy is seen as a way of asking major Russian depositors – who regularly use Cyprus as an offshore banking venue – to contribute to saving the country’s banks, though the deal has been condemned by the Russian government which said it should have been consulted first.

From Russia with…

It is thought that the Cypriot government itself is keen to ensure that the levy applies to all account holders, and not just offshore depositors, in order to maintain good relations with Moscow – which is already a major lender to the Cypriot government, who had hoped for an improvement on the repayment conditions.

“The Eurogroup looks forward to an agreement between Cyprus and the Russian Federation on a financial contribution,” Dijsselbloem said in his statement last night.

The levy will be used to recapitalise the country’s two biggest banks, with shares given to account holders as compensation. The banks have faced capital shortages since the EU-approved partial default on Greek government debt last year.

An extraordinary bank holiday has been declared on the island for today, in order to ensure that banks remain closed while the measures are finalised. Yesterday was already a scheduled bank holiday, and banks themselves have been ordered not to open until Thursday to avoid a possible bank run.

Attention in the meantime turns to the parliament in Nicosia, where no party has a majority in the House of Representatives and where talks have been continuing to try and secure the support of smaller parties.

The vote had originally been due on Sunday evening, but had been delayed to yesterday and again to today so that Nicos Anastasiades – who only became president three weeks ago – could have more time to secure the necessary support.

Poll: Is Cyprus right to tax people’s savings?

  • Share on Facebook
  • Email this article
  •  

Read next:

Comments (52 Comments)

  • The largest transfer of wealth from the working and middle classes to the wealthy in living memory continues unabated. At what point do people stand up and say enough is enough? The bankers and the their accomplices in government will not stop until they have stripped the rest of us of our belongings. This is classic “shock doctrine” stuff – where the elites make use of a crisis to force measures upon us which we would not accept under “normal” circumstances. How long will we put up with this state of emergency/suspended democracy? We’ve had it for half a decade now. At what point do people realize that this isn’t simply a suspension of democracy and the rule of law – but instead the new normal – a form of permanent Corporatist-Fascism?

    Reply
    • @ Shane. Well said. It’s time people realised this and said enough….

      Reply
    • History will judge these fascists worse than Hitler, their economic policies will send millions to an early grave. This is only the begining, there is plenty more coming down the line.

      Reply
    • Unfortunately there will be no protest here, the Irish have no backbone.

      Reply
    • Genius 19/03/13 #

      Ireland’s Response.
      If we all keep quiet and say nothing it will all be grand they will pick on someone else.

      Reply
    • Bit early for Godwins isn’t it

      Reply
    • Genius 19/03/13 #

      Godwin’s Law me arse, This is fact.

      Reply
    • I’ll have to assume you don’t know what the word ‘fact’ means then. It’s not the same as ‘opinion’. don’t feel bad though, its a very common problem in the Comments section.

      Reply
    • Saing something is no longer enough – we have to act by kicking out the enemies of the Nation – those who take their orders from the bankers and Finance World . If the Law will not prosecute them – its time to get rid of them . but how many will act – we rae great talkers – not so hot on taking on the estblisment . Some even believe Gilmore is a ”socialist ”– and are afarid of ” Socilaism ” – which in fact does not exist to any great extent except for the Banks . The social democracies of Nordic countries seem to be faring much better – a far better example to follow than US and it ” American Nightmare ” .
      Also – the following by the people of election of new pope – of more than doubtful status re his actions or rather non actions in Argentine – does not bode well .
      @Derek Durkin – History may well judge them ok – they are the Victors – from NY to Llondon – they have swept all before them . they will doubless kill more than Mr H – who actually brought in a 40 hour week and paid overtime – and concert halls in larger factories etc .
      It was disatrous that he had such a hatred for Jews – and what he did

      Reply
    • Godwin’s Law? That’s just plain lazy.

      Reply
    • Not nearly as lazy as irrelevant hitler/fascism references

      Reply
    • @ Derek – Lay off the “Hitler” name-dropping please. It’s easy to do for someone whose family wasn’t directly affected by his regime, but it’s extremely annoying for people who have family who were.

      The EU has not setup death camps. The EU has not forced homosexuals to brand themselves with pink triangles to identify themselves as sub-humans. The EU has not euthanised the disabled and sterilised the parents of children who were born with disabilities.

      The analogy is both facile and factually incorrect.

      Reply
    • Genocide is genocide in my book. Different methods, same result. The driving up of food & energy prices combined with mass austerity not only in Europe but across the world will result in the deaths of millions of people. It’ll be a longer process, think of it a more humane 21st century genocide. My apologies for using Hitler as reference but this has happened through out our history,people shouldn’t be naive to think it can’t happen anymore.

      Reply
    • The comparison doesn’t hold. Rising food prices is not the same as rounding people up, packing them into cattle-cars, shipping them to a KZ and then shooting/gassing them and burning the bodies once anything of possible of value has been removed from the bodies.

      It’s just no the same thing, and if you really think that they are the same, then you should count your blessings that you live at a time and in a country where the proof that they are not the same thing is not something that has been forced upon you or your family.

      Please have a bit of perspective.

      Reply
    • “Poverty is the worst form of violence” – Ghandi. Its by refusing to put them in the same bracket is the reason they get away with it.

      Reply
  • The EU policy makers couldn’t have made a bigger mess if they had tried according to one American finanical reporter yesterday.

    Reply
    • random 19/03/13 #

      He/she is not wrong. Stealth taxes and property taxes are one thing, but trying to take a percentage of peoples deposits is inevitably going to cause a bank run, and that is even more likely to cause the banks to collapse than the problem they’re trying to solve with the bailout!

      Reply
    • Ryan'O 19/03/13 #

      We’ve (Europe) have been tip toeing around the gun powder for the past number of years and now they decide to play with matches at this particular time. It’s crazy, the contagion will hit Italy and snowball on.

      Reply
    • true but you are never going to solve a problem with the same mindset that created it in the first place. People have to realise that the elite are usurping ALL the wealth of countries very slowly. Its a very scary situation and people have no idea its happeningm , here and everywhere else. The corporations are trying to make us penniless/

      Reply
    • Well the US is no great place either – and actually it was from the US that this accursed Neo liberal conomics came – that has laid waste much of the ” west ”
      @Pat Mc Goo – if the people do not know what is happening now after five years – they will never know . Like the info s there by the ton in many sites – so why do people not know ??

      Reply
  • Household charge
    Septic tank charge
    Property tax
    Water rates
    Pension Levy
    Income Levy
    Stamp Duty

    All taxes… Some of which over lap and hit the same people many times. We are being fleeced all the time. How many more taxes can our government invent to keep paying back toxic bank debt. NOT OUR DEBT..

    Reply
  • B Lowe 19/03/13 #

    Socialism being used to bail out capitalism.
    A precedent has been set for the EU, could happen anytime again for any amount.
    Any chance the banks will take all the losses in this like when they take all the profits when there doing good? Not a chance. Nope, good old socialism for the middle classes.

    Reply
  • Their finance minister said on channel 4 news that his president is being forced by Europe to bring in the levy and then as he went to explain futher, the link went down and he was stopped from talking more about it.

    Reply
    • b 19/03/13 #

      They are going after the dirty Russian money plain and simple. The place is awash with it and that is the reason they are treating Cyprus differently. No London or New York investment houses getting burned here.

      Reply
    • sean 19/03/13 #

      No b , they are not simply after the russian money ,
      After all , when orders from russia come in for thousands of BMW,s Audi’s , and Mercs , no ones asks wherenall the money for those comes from .
      Whats happening in cyprus is simply the next step of financial desperation , a certain group of people want every available penny , before the whole thing collapses . servicing debt , with debt ……only 1 outcome

      In the true words of max keiser, only leave the money your willing to lose ,in your bank account

      Reply
    • Two billion Russian money already gone. Tipped off by insiders in the banks. Got to lurve them bankers!

      Reply
    • @b: I think you may be right on that. I hope so, anyway!

      Reply
  • When Noonan and Co hit all of us with this one off savings tax it wont be an announcement in advance like in Cypyus, it will be taken overnight and then some spew the next day that they understand the sacrifices we have made..

    Reply
  • They don’t know what they are doing ,they are only doing what they are told BUT you can be sure the politician,s won’t loose no matter which country they come from

    Reply
  • Who loves the E.U at the moment. What a great place. Austerity first. Now direct bank theft. What next?

    Reply
  • It wouldn’t surprise me that every Thursday and Friday before the next Bank Holidays everyone will be taking what meager savings they have out of the Irish banks, just in case!

    Reply
  • A disgrace to rob savers of their money to cover the punt made on Greek debt by the banks, the European dream is long dead, the next generation of Germans will be a hated breed which is the saddest part, these times were a chance for Europe to really become a union were the stronger helps to weaker for the common good but we all know what has happened ..

    Reply
  • “Lets make a plan”, said the Cypriot Prime minister “Doesn’t have to be complicated, in fact the less so the better. We don’t require any complex “lets get pissed in the Dail bar before we embezzle” middle of the night sort of stuff like the Irish, what we need here is something simple. You see we need to steal some cash for the IMF, we also need to fly a flag or two to see how much cash we can steal so as to gauge the mood in terms the amount we propose to legally withdraw from our constituents”.

    “Those constituents holding less than €100,000 won’t be happy with a 3.24% differential between themselves and those wealthier account holders enjoying a balance in excess of that amount” said one rather insightful member of the Cypriot cabinet.

    “I have no Kidnap/Ransom insurance” said another well dressed but rather worried looking member of the Cypriot cabinet to the rest.

    “Yes indeed, nor do I, what will we do about the Russians?” they cried in unison.

    “Yes, the Russians, well if we steal less from them and illustrate our willingness to steal more from others, perhaps then they might spare some of us a sightseeing tour of the Mediterranean to investigate the breeding habits of the Great White Shark, which I might add, rather inconveniently inhabit our shores”

    “Can we not simply get stinking drunk and introduce an IBRC style approach to fiscal governance in the middle of the night when everyone is asleep?” suggested a visiting Irish delegate as he loudly cracked another can.

    “Afraid not, the IMF insist that the Jackie Chan “Drunken Master” style approach utilized by the Irish is a once only deal, and that you will all sadly have to remain sober when the Cypriot cabinet moves to steal from it’s constituents.”

    A pause, followed by a silence signaled the universal acceptance of yet another great move by the IMF in it’s move for the collective colonic that personified it’s management of European affairs.

    “So we’re done here I think.” concluded the Prime Minister and yet he felt compelled to state the obvious.

    “In closing I would like to remind you all that you have 24 hours to move all your cash holdings to an offshore entity located in the Bahamas as previously arranged, those of you lucky enough to hold Bank Bills ,Bonds or Promissory notes in Liechtenstein would be advised to contact your local IMF fund management specialist through our Irish intermediary here. He currently has a property investment portfolio that hides rather well in plain sight, NAMA I think it’s called,which as it happens has a rather firm grip on the FOI legislative mechanism. I’m sure when he sobers up a little that he will be more than happy to get drunk again and explain how it all works for the top 5% of the food chain in his native land.”

    The only sound to be heard following this advice was the pitter patter of custom made shoes as the Cypriot parliament steadily made their way across the hallowed hall to the Irish delegate, who by now could hardly speak but yet still managed to sharpen a pencil or two whilst “setting out his stall” in anticipation of an extraordinary influx of brand spanking new foreign capital.

    Reply
  • We have already been mugged with Universal levy and VAT at record levels now property tax and water tax on the way and what have we done about it and what has anybody else done for us.
    We, along with the Germans are the most despised people in Europe.

    Reply
  • Bill 19/03/13 #

    Proof yet again that the Capitalist model is very near its end and on life support kindly supplied by the workers the poor and the unemployed .

    Reply
  • The EU has shown its hand, the well being of banks and politicos is there soul interest.
    Citizens well being quality of life are not considered. Time for this empire to END. In 20 yrs. there will be more emigrants then ethnic Europeans in the EU, we must think now and vote (forgot for a mo that we have no democracy in the EU anymore) .
    Do we want sharia law in 20-30 years from now in Europe. Look at the big picture there is no plan for the future
    of citizens only the banks health is considered, disaster ahead.

    Reply
  • Controlled media won’t ask any questions about who the real power behind the banks are. Noonan is fast turning into the bilderbergs dream lieutenant. Corporations now bigger than governments and people don’t know how to deal with it.

    Reply
  • Is the increase in the filth tax here not the same scam?

    Reply
  • Why Russian people did not invest their money into OUR economy???!! It could save us!!!!!!!!!!! Now it’s too late :(

    Reply
  • RUSSIA rules Cyprus WOW! That’s a surprise!!

    Reply
  • Ah lads. Cop on a bit please. There’s no way the EU is going to bail out the Russian mafia who use Cyprus to launder money. A charge on balances over €100k is entirely reasonable under the circumstances. Refusing to touch senior bondholders is a different matter altogether though.

    Reply
    • sean 19/03/13 #

      Cyprus will reject the deal , russia wil save cyprus in return for a %of cyprus untouched gas reserves .

      I,m more worried about merkel and the eu mafia , than the russian mafia

      Reply
    • Two billion already gone and no doubts the super rich Russians are already in cahoots to get more away. Bankers and the super rich got to lurve the proximity of the two. Next we’ll be thinking that certain political parties look after the super rich..

      Reply
    • Russian businessmen and organised criminals having a tax-haven in which they can dictate and which is inside the EU is something for EU countries to be rightly worried about.

      There is a lot of talk about a nation’s sovereignty over the past months. Cyprus may lose their sovereignty though a bail-out deal with the EU bi-wigs, but they definitely lose their soveignity through a exclusively Russian bail-out. If it’s a choice of who will be their new master, Russia may not be the safer option.

      The other point that, if it were a choice of owing €17 million to the ECB / ESM ( as originally applied for ), and owing €10 million to the EU instruments with the bank depositor levy and national asset sale, which would be more damaging to the long-term sovereignty of the country?

      There’s been a big u-turn in the opinions of the regular commenters here, as up until now they’ve taken a very clear stance of “owing more = bad”, but one this issue it has been completely reversed.

      For example, if the banks had not been recapitalised in Ireland, it would be inevitable that the depositors would have been hit, retrospective guarantee or no. But this is put forward as a more preferable option to what had actually happened.

      So why is it considered wrong that Cyprus tries to minimise the amount it must borrow from the EU to stay afloat?

      Reply
    • Guy stop talking rubbish! Please!!!!! A well known fact: Most of Russian money in Cyprus banks DO NOT belong to any kind of mafia. The money (millions of euros) belong to ordinary Russian people. It’s just happens that Russians are very wealthy and nobody in the western countries knew about this wealth. Surprise…surprise! ;)

      Reply
  • Work hard, be sensible with your mn

    Reply

Add New Comment