Business ETC uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 8 °C Wednesday 22 May, 2013

Credit ratings of ALL European nations under threat, warns Moody’s

The ratings agency said “multiple defaults” are now a possibility, and that more than one country could be forced to leave the euro.

Image: Mark Lennihan/AP/Press Association Images

RATINGS AGENCY MOODY’S has warned that the creditworthiness of every European nation is under threat as the eurozone debt crisis continues to worsen.

In a special announcement, the agency stated that “multiple defaults” are on the horizon, and flagged the possibility that more than one country could be forced to leave the euro.

The statement will reinforce the view that high-profile measures and deals struck by EU leaders will not be sufficient to contain the debt crisis. It was reported yesterday that Italy could require an unprecedented €600billion intervention from the IMF.

Moody’s warned that its analysts expect the situation to worsen before there is sufficient political will to take decisive action. “In the absence of policy measures that stabilise market conditions over the short term [...] credit risk will continue to rise,” it said, adding that “the political impetus to implement an effective resolution plan may only emerge after a series of shocks”.

The probability of multiple defaults (in addition to Greece’s private sector involvement programme) by euro area countries is no longer negligible [...] A series of defaults would also significantly increase the likelihood of one or more members not simply defaulting, but also leaving the euro area.

Greece and Italy were flagged as the greatest risks for sparking instability. The agency said the eurozone was “approaching a junction” which would lead either to closer integration between countries or greater fragmentation, with serious implications for countries’ creditworthiness.

“The point is likely to be reached where the overall architecture of Moody’s ratings within the euro area, and possibly elsewhere within the EU, will need to be revisited,” the statement said.

Widespread downgrades would be likely to worsen the eurozone’s problems, as many large investment vehicles such as pension funds are contractually bound only to hold securities above a certain rating. Downgrades would force these investors into a major sell-off of sovereign bonds, increasing interest rates and making it harder for nations to secure funding.

Read more: IMF preparing €600bn of assistance for Italy – report>

Read next:

Comments (13 Comments)

  • Kildare 28/11/11 #

    Maybe it’s time to give junk status to Moody and other agencies?

    Reply
    • Neil 28/11/11 #

      If a country borrows money then it’s at their mercy. The only way to avoid them is not to borrow. Full stop.

      But can you imagine the ‘budget’ we would have if the governent had to fully balance income and expenditure?. Forget about the 10 euro on childrens allowance being a concern.

      Reply
  • Rating agencies should not be allowed to contribute to sensational journalism. It contributes to and accelerates market opinion. They should do ratings full stop. Not make statements that countries are at risk of a downgrade. How on earth can any EU country go to the bond market now and expect to have a good auction.
    One has to feel there is some political agenda from inside Moodys.

    Reply
  • So it will be a level playing field?

    Reply
  • Aisling 28/11/11 #

    Completely agree with Cormac above.

    Every time these agencies suggest that something may happen it causes panic, and makes the situation worse than it already may be.

    They should just comment when they’re making a downgrade. They should warn those in the power in the countries that there is a risk to their creditworthiness, but leave it at that.

    I know they want to make investors aware of potential problems, but it’s not helping the countries regain any sense of control of the situation, as I’ve said, it just worsens it.

    Reply
    • Also see a political motivation – maybe my viewpoint is a bit simplistic here, but isn’t it better for currency speculators to have lots of smaller fluctuating currencies to one big steady one?

      Reply
    • Aisling 28/11/11 #

      @Niall There is definitely something political going on. I’m very suspicious and wary of the rating agencies on a whole – when they choose to talk about things, when they choose to announce their downgrades.

      Not quite sure regarding the currency, I’d like to agree as it would make sense. Currency, investments etc. are definitely not my strong point.

      Reply
  • Dear Moody’s, Standard & Poor et al….. Shut the hell up and jog on From, us.

    Sick and tired of this lot and their self fulfilling prophecies.

    Reply
  • Pure sensationalistic attention-seeking on the part of the ratings agencies. How else can they make such sweeping statements about such a large number of countries? Within the Eurozone itself, we have countries like Estonia with a 6.5% debt to GDP ratio and Luxembourg with 19% in comparison to our place just short of the 100% mark, Greece’s 142% and Italy’s 146%.

    Reply
  • Just a quick question for those of you with more knowledge than myself: With the euro situation getting worse by the minute and negative speculation making things even more difficult, will all of Ireland’s “best in class” behaviour have been for nothing? Just looking for honest opinions

    Reply
    • I wouldn’t claim to know more than anyone else, but my feeling is that there was no benefit to Ireland in blindly propping up the Euro, at all costs. I think that the threat of default is about the only card we’ve got, and we should have used it judiciously to extract softer terms from the troika.

      Instead, we’ve gone all in on the Euro’s survival through the policy decisions taken in the past few months – extended bank guarantee, etc. – so I sincerely do hope that it does survive, the consequences of its collapsing would be catastrophic.

      Reply
  • Danny D 28/11/11 #

    Not sure why is my name Kildare here after posting from an iPhone. TheJournal?

    Reply

Add New Comment