Welcome to our Public Beta Site - What does this mean?
Dublin: 11 °C Wednesday 16 May, 2012

Bank customers may be “discouraged” from switching accounts

Image: Chase Lindberg via Flickr.com

RESEARCH CARRIED OUT on behalf of the Central Bank on how easy – or not – banks make it for customers to switch current accounts has thrown up some concerns.

The Central Bank made an on-site inspection at the four main banks and found that there was a low level of switching accounts – only 6,114 current accounts (that’s 0.16 per cent of all current accounts in those banks) were switched between October 2010 and June 2011. The Central Bank said that communication with customers on the benefits and process of switching accounts was “poor”; that complaints related to switching were not always categorised as such; banks didn’t keep track of all relevant documentation to show they were in compliance with the Switching Code and not all the banks regularly reviewed their switching processes.

A mystery shopping exercise was carried out in September this year in 60 bank branches by a third party on behalf of the Central Bank. The exercise found:

  • Only half of the mystery shoppers felt encouraged to switch after the visit
  • Bank staff needed more training and awareness of the Switching Code
  • Only half of staff mentioned the Code spontaneously when the mystery shopper said they wanted to move accounts
  • One-fifth asked the mystery shoppers to make an appointment with a specific staff member rather than deal with them themselves
  • A switching information pack was only proffered in half the visits – and half of those were incomplete
  • Explanations of how standing orders, direct debits and salary payments would be dealt with were provided on just over half the visits.

The Central Bank said that one bank was found to be “particularly unsatisfactory” in its dealings with customers in this area and they have been instructed to make improvements by the end of next February. The other three were given feedback from the mystery shopper visits and have been asked to report back to the Central Bank on how they will improve their service.

Read Next:

Comments (12 Comments)

  • holeymoley 17/12/11 #
    Report this comment

    Who was the unsatisfactory bank?

    Reply
  • Dec Rowe 17/12/11 #
    Report this comment

    This is the stupidest article ever!!! If you want to switch account then it’s as simple as telling a new bank “hi, I’d like to switch accounts please” I’ve switched accounts from 3 banks in the last 5 years… And had no issues!

    Reply
    • Susan Daly 17/12/11 #
      Report this comment

      Er… thanks for the “stupid” bit there Dec.
      To clarify, the point of the article is that while you might know what you want when you walk into the bank, plenty of consumers don’t and need some help to get the best possible rates/reduced charges etc. Yes, it can be easy to switch accounts but – if as the research carried out for the survey shows – banks make it seem like a hassle and/or don’t give the information people need, then it can put people off getting the best deal for themselves.
      I think that is worth highlighting.
      Hi @holeymoley – trying to establish that. The CB won’t specify…

    • userwrites 17/12/11 #
      Report this comment

      Susan I might not have used the same words as Dec but agree with his basic point. Surely the CB should be spending time & money more carefully?

    • Eamonn Clancy 17/12/11 #
      Report this comment

      Yeah, there’s still a wimpy Irish public out there with no spine. I’ve done it twice the year because of bad service.

    • Paul Mallon 18/12/11 #
      Report this comment

      We’ve just changed banks a couple of months ago and we had major problems getting all our DD’s transferred, ended up having to do it all ourselves. Bit of a joke.

  • Fluffy Button 17/12/11 #
    Report this comment

    Pity the Central Bank didn’t do their jobs over the boom years and rein in the banks then. Now they do some pathetic “mystery shopping” to justify their big salaries.

    Reply
  • Shane Gleeson 17/12/11 #
    Report this comment

    Ridiculous PR from the CBI. The banks should be named and shamed

    Reply
  • G Charles Osborne 17/12/11 #
    Report this comment

    The entire excercise is nonsense if the Central Bank wont publish the report and name the banks involved. It’s bizarre that they wouldn’t.

    Reply
  • Auntie Dote 17/12/11 #
    Report this comment

    Another anecdotal problem. Customer looking for business credit is told its not worth applying. No application, no recorded credit refusal. Not everyone is strong minded enough to insist on making an application likely to fail just to get it on record.

    Reply
  • Rodger O Waters 17/12/11 #
    Report this comment

    Another issue last week I tried to close an account that had matured and eventually surrendered and left it for another year,banks must be under serious pressure to retain funds.

    Reply
  • Dec Rowe 19/12/11 #
    Report this comment

    Sorry to be harsh but I kind of get a pain in my backside listening to people complain about things being difficult when they are actully not! Yes things could be easier and the banks know this but let’s face it, switching a bank account or setting up a DD is quite simple now a days if you have access to a pc or smart phone or a half a brain, and if you dont I’m sure there’s somebody that you know who does!

    Reply

Add New Comment