Business ETC uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 10 °C Friday 24 May, 2013

“Reject Ryanair”: Aer Lingus in third recommendation to shareholders

Airline’s board is extremely clear on where it stands on the takeover bid.

Cabin crew staff from Aer Lingus and Ryanair getting on just fine.
Cabin crew staff from Aer Lingus and Ryanair getting on just fine.
Image: Mark Stedman/Photocall Ireland

THE BOARD OF Aer Lingus has reiterated its recommendation to shareholders that they should reject an offer tabled by Ryanair last month.

In a written statement this morning, the airline said it had received no new information from its rival since it last wrote to shareholders on 31 July.

The unanimous view at the boardroom table is that the €1.30 per share cash offer from Ryanair “fundamentally undervalues” the company.

“Aer Lingus is a strong and profitable airline with a proven business model; a strong balance sheet; and an internationally recognised and valued brand,” board members said.

They added that the takeover bid “represents a significant discount to the intrinsic value of the business”.

Based on careful consideration of the issues, and extensive legal and financial advice, the board remains of the view that Ryanair’s offer is not in the interests of shareholders, fundamentally undervalues the business and, due to the scale and extent of competition issues, is likely once more to be prohibited by the European Commission. Accordingly, the board unanimously recommends shareholders take no action in relation to the offer and should not sign any document sent by Ryanair or its advisors.

This is the third written rejection recommendation issued by Aer Lingus to its shareholders.

On 17 July, Ryanair made a formal bid of €694 million for Aer Lingus. The offer will remain open until 3pm on 13 September this year.

In his attempts to convince shareholders to sell, CEO Michael O’Leary said Aer Lingus has “failed to deliver value” in its six years as a public company. He believes that significant changes in the air transport market in Europe will allow for the consolidation.

Ryanair already owns 29.82 per cent of the issued share capital of Aer Lingus but has failed in two other attempts to purchase a majority holding.

Earlier: Ryanair makes €694 million bid for Aer Lingus>

Related: Ryanair won’t comment on Aer Lingus takeover ‘speculation’>

More: Ryanair’s next big idea: bigger doors on planes so people can board faster>

Read next:

Comments (9 Comments)

  • You would!

    Reply
  • This is SOP when mounting a defence against a hostile takeover. There will be another letter to shareholders the week before the deadline for acceptance.

    It is true that the takeover offer from Ryanair significantly undervalues the business so one has to assume that the purpose was to flush out a rival bid at a higher price to enable Ryanair to off load it’s stake at reasonable value. Doesn’t seem to be working.

    Reply
  • If O’Leary ever manages to get his greedy hands on Aer Lingus expect fares in and out of Ireland to double or treble in price. A monopoly is never to for the consumer. And God help us – we have Leo Varadkar looking after our interests!

    Reply
    • John F 24/08/12 #

      That’s right Con because there are only 2 airlines that fly out of Ireland right?? Aer Lingus and Ryanair are practically indistinguishable, Aer Lingus latest cabin bag policy has proved that, I say give Aer Lingus over to somebody with a track record of running a successful business, get rid of the union!

      Reply
  • As if Aer Lingus are going to recommend anything else! The very fact that they’ve issued the same recommendation three times sounds like they’re panicking a little bit though!

    Reply
    • Sounds like they’re anything but panicking… Seems like they’re sending an intern down with a 2 line press statement saying ‘our position hasn’t changed’ and getting on with running their business knowing this is another attempt by a rival to dent its public image

      Reply
  • I would hate to see the governments shareholding of Aer Lingus or the majority shareholding fall into the hands of some corrupt Middle Eastern dictator family business (cough – Emirates and Etihad). This will happen because of the constant rejections of Ryanair’s bids and the government want to sell their 25% holding. Despite many peoples disliking of Ryanair, it is a much more successful business than Aer Lingus and it is the best for Ireland that Aer Lingus is taken over by Ryanair than some potential Arab family and all revenue would be lost.

    Reply
    • Barro 24/08/12 #

      Ryanair is cost effective, can’t fault them for anything. Many dislike them because they flew without reading the ts&cs or have no understanding of the business model.

      Personally cannot see it increasing prices ten fold as they would still operate on seperate routes, its a takeover, not an amalgamation.

      Reply
  • Yeah, aer lingus is profitable – for now… Wait until unions get their next hissy fit and the state will be pumping more capital into it. Better offload it to someone who can run a company without a safety net

    Reply

Add New Comment